Reviews of Mystic Bay
If you would like to send a review of the book, please email us at office@hayden-lakespublishing.com.
After finishing Mystic Bay, I didn’t jump back into anything right away. That night was actually pretty normal, I still had a market analysis to go through. My laptop was open, the file was right there… but I just didn’t click into it. I closed the book, leaned back in my chair, and just sat there. It was quiet outside. My phone buzzed a couple of times, I saw it, but I didn’t reach for it. That moment felt unusual for me. I didn’t switch back into work mode. I didn’t rush to respond or process anything. I just… paused. And honestly, that kind of pause feels like a luxury to me.
For years, my life has been highly structured, projects, capital allocation, risk assessment, return cycles. Everything has a logic, a rhythm, a next step. I’m used to moving forward. I’m used to making decisions quickly. I rarely let myself sit with a feeling for too long. But this book created a subtle sense of distance for me. The story itself isn’t complicated. In fact, it’s slow. A small town, a quiet bay, old houses, and relationships unfolding over time. There’s no dramatic conflict driving everything forward.
And maybe that’s exactly why it pulls you in, because it’s the details that stay with you. Take Dan, for example. When I got to the part where he sold his company, I paused. Not because it was surprising, but because it felt so real. A lot of people would see that as a move toward freedom. But to me, it felt more like, a decision made after carrying too much for too long. That kind of life… I understand it.
Constant decision-making. Every choice has consequences. People are always waiting on you for answers. You don’t get to hesitate. You don’t get to be emotional. And over time, something happens, you become very… functional. You’re still sharp, efficient, rational. But you stop asking yourself one simple question: Am I doing this because I truly want to… or just because I’ve always been doing it?
So when he walked away, I didn’t see it as escape. If anything, it felt like honesty. Beth brought a different kind of energy into the story. She wasn’t there to “change” him. She felt more like someone who made it okay to slow down. She didn’t push him to explain his past. She didn’t ask him to prove anything about the future. I really loved the scenes where they were out on the water. Nothing really happens. No major plot movement. No turning points. Just the wind, the ocean, the horizon… and two people sharing quiet moments. And somehow, that kind of “nothing happening” felt incredibly safe.
It made me realize something, Most of the relationships we build in life are driven by something. Emotional needs, value alignment, future expectations. But the ones that truly feel restful… are the ones where you don’t have to perform. Courtney’s storyline hit me in a completely different way. She’s searching for the truth about the past, going through old things, revisiting places, even reliving fragments through dreams. That process felt very real to me. Because in real life, most people don’t do that. We move forward. We don’t look back. But some things don’t just disappear because we choose not to face them.
At one point, I put the book down and walked into the kitchen to get a glass of water. And standing there, I found myself thinking, If I look at life through the lens I’m most familiar with, assets, returns, growth, efficiency… are those things still the most important ones over a long enough timeline? Or are they just…what we’re meant to focus on during a certain phase of life? Mystic Bay, to me, stopped being just a place.
It felt more like a state of being. A place where you don’t have to prove anything. Where you don’t have to make decisions. Where you’re not responsible for outcomes. You just exist. You just feel. And honestly, that kind of state feels unfamiliar to me. I’m used to being in control. Planning ahead. Reducing uncertainty. Making sense of everything through logic. But this book made me realize something important, If life is always about moving forward, that in itself becomes a kind of imbalance. Maybe a more mature place to be is this: You have the ability to keep pushing forward… but you also have the choice to slow down.
Not because you can’t keep going, but because you don’t always want to stay in that state. After finishing the book, I didn’t change my plans. Work is still there. Decisions still need to be made. But I do carry a slightly different awareness now: As I continue building, investing, and making rational choices, maybe I should also leave a little space for myself, a space not driven by efficiency, not defined by outcomes, not influenced by external expectations.
Maybe just an evening here and there… no data, no decisions, just stillness. It sounds simple. But it’s not easy. This book didn’t give me answers. But it showed me a different rhythm of life. And sometimes, just seeing that another way exists… is already powerful enough.
Irina S
Spokane, WA
What a story! The intrigue, suspense, and romance really did keep me turning pages.
You’ve done something really good here.
Will Salyards, PhD
Tennessee
As an avid reader I’m always eager to find an author who writes in a way that captures my interest right from the start. Mystic Bay is a novel that did just that! A great read that kept me guessing and questioning the outcome of characters. Great book. I couldn’t put it down.
Kari Kerr
Deer Park, WA
I liked it. I don’t read much fiction these days, but the sweep of this captivated me. Your cross-generational approach, coupled with the fact that you are comfortable going both backwards and forwards in time, makes for a challenging read, but a rewarding one. Thanks for using the last part of the book to tie up loose ends. Finishing Beth’s story was necessary and the insights into Dan’s life were revealing, even if he didn’t happen to know all the facts himself.
The only critical comment I make is this: The segues: There is a lot in between, but the intricate details about sailing seem to establish a theme of detail. Detail that left me guessing from time-to-time. Eventually you tied all the details together, successfully, thank you.
I think you have a winner here.
Steve Wehrenberg, PhD
Washington, DC
I absolutely loved Mystic Bay! From the very first page, I was completely drawn in by the emotional depth and vivid storytelling. The journey of Dan, navigating grief and healing through the promise he made, was both powerful and heartfelt. I genuinely couldn’t put it down—every chapter pulled me further into the world created.
The writing is beautifully paced, with just the right balance of introspection and movement. The author has a real talent for capturing raw human emotion while wrapping it in a compelling, almost cinematic setting. I found myself not just reading the story, but feeling it.
This is one of those books that stays with you long after you’ve finished the last page. I highly recommend it to everyone.
Rebecca Mulvaney
Coeur d’ Alene, Idaho
